Should a bumper be repaired or replaced?
It comes down to the damage and the cost of each route. Repair makes sense for surface scuffs, shallow cracks away from mounting points and small dents in flexible plastic. Replacement makes sense when the cover is split across, the mounting tabs are broken or the shape is badly distorted.
A replacement cover usually arrives unpainted, so it still needs primer, color and clear coat before it goes on the car. Paint is where a lot of the cost sits, which is why a replacement is not always much more expensive than a repair. Used covers in the right color can save money but may carry their own wear.
Trucks sometimes have steel or chrome bumpers instead, which are repaired in a different way, through straightening or replacement. Ask for the reasoning behind any recommendation, and for a written estimate that shows both options when both are realistic.

